home album reviews live reviews links lists f.a.q. other stuff and nonsense

 

 

Go to:


The Stooges ( 1969 )

8

1969 / I Wanna Be Your Dog / We Will Fall / No Fun / Real Cool Time / Ann / Not Right / Little Doll

The StoogesThis must be one of 1969’s dirtiest releases. Maybe not the heaviest album from the era (Blue Cheer’s Vincebus Eruptum (1968) or Led Zeppelin’s debut?), but you can’t deny that large parts of this album are downright weird to have been released in the year that also brought us Let It Bleed, Tommy, Arthur and The Soft Parade. Yeah, I mentioned those albums on purpose, because I’m convinced that they were made by bands who must have influenced The Stooges (in)directly. These bands, and the Velvet Underground of course. They took The Who’s primal power, added The Kinks’ early simplicity, The Stones’ sleaze, The Doors’ theatrics, and finally a VU-obsession with distortion and drones.The music on this album sounds exactly how those four guys on the front and back cover look: ugly, primitive, and scruffy. Not yet dangerous, but definitely more perverted than The Rolling Stones would ever look or sound. Still, John Cale (who also produced other classic proto-punk debuts The Modern Lovers (released in 1976, recorded in 1973) and Patti Smith’s Horses (1975)) could have done a better job, since some of the songs have a flat production that makes different song parts almost undistinguishable. Well, they weren’t exactly great songwriters at the time, of course, but that doesn’t imply that each song should be treated as monotonous drone, right?

“1969” starts off really good, though, with a dirty wah-wah sound, and a typically repeated drum pattern (Scott Asheton never proved he could provide more than some basic drumming, but that’s exactly what he did like no one else before or after him) over which Ron Asheton’s grinding distortion and fuzzed guitars and Iggy Pop’s snarly vocals sound really cool. A track that today still rocks like hell. Something which is also true of “I Wanna Be Your Dog,” a primitive slab of raw and menacing rock ‘n roll that makes good use of sleigh bells and a fuzzy guitar solo. I’d better delete that last part, since all the songs here have savagely unsubtle guitar solos. Except for “We Will Fall,” a lengthy ‘song’ that almost succeeds in ruining the album’s appeal. Droning along for more than ten minutes, and obviously VU-inspired (Cale provides some viola in the background), it has some awkward hypnotic chanting (is that English?), while Iggy utters some silly lines. It is obvious on this track, though, that Iggy was at this stage very much influenced by Jim Morrison’s equally bombastic stage presence; just listen how he seems to imitate the Lizard King’s sleazy pronunciation (an insightful book to check out more of the Morrison-Pop link is definitely Danny Sugerman’s tale of ‘glamour and excess’, Wonderland Avenue).

The second side of the album contains some more good stuff: “No Fun” is another raw and lengthy track, with Iggy really freaking out this time (“Well, come oooooohhhhnn!!”), and Asheton churning out another fucked up solo. An example of a song almost ruined by the production is “Real Cool Time,” a short and monotonous but sinister-sounding track that suggests our gentleman caller isn’t out for a dance at the local ball (and 22 years later, The Feelies would put a definitive version of this song on their masterpiece Time For A Witness). “Ann” has more primitive drums and more Morrison-inflected crooning along with another distorted solo, but is the second side’s weakest track. The following track, “Not Right,” isn’t especially impressive, either, but this time it has a guitar solo that sounds really cool and not over-fuzzed; this sound would reappear on albums by The Butthole Surfers (really, Paul Leary must have been directly influenced by stuff like this). “Little Doll,” the album closer, is an unashamed rehashing of “1969” (with a few more cymbal crashes added), but that’s a good thing I guess.

The Stooges is a bit of a one-dimensional album that doesn’t have much to offer in the songwriting and accomplished musicianship-department. On the other hand, that’s exactly a part of their appeal, as the band proved that basic instrumentation, an oversized attitude, and a willingness to try new things (they weren’t just copycats, but innovators) could get them a record contract and a fine debut album. Taking rock ‘n roll further back to its liberating core as a means of expression, The Stooges would further ‘refine’ on their attack on their second album, which would prove to be the band’s masterpiece.

Reader comments:


Zophael979:
I started off as a guy who picked up a copy of Black Flag's Damaged and absolutely loved it. I knew the Stooges were an influence to them, as well as the Ramones (and yeah, all punk rock in general). So I took a listen to the first album and...

It wasn't what I expected.

No fast songs. No horrid violence in the music. Slow tempos. Fuzzed out guitar solos. Iggy's classic drawl (not yet his horrid screams). Still, "1969" and "I Wanna Be Your Dog" both struck me as great initially and the rest of the album followed suit with repeated listens. "1969" is the perfect introduction to the band. First with the fuzzed out guitar solo (obvious influence on Mudhoney, another favorite of mine), then the minimalstic groove of the bass and drums, followed by Iggy's powerfully bored sneer "Well, it's 1969 okkaaayyyy...". A great song, miraciously topped by the second track. "I Wanna Be Your Dog" is perverted, dark, and really friggin heavy for a song recorded in 1969. The best song on the album and probably by second favorite Stooges number, right under "Search and Destroy".

The rest of the album isn't quite up to par, but never really slips into medocrity...much. "No Fun" is another early punk classic, but suffers from being a tad overlong. "Real Cool Time" is a short, sweet, heavily distorted drone with, as you put it, a sinister sound. "Ann", the quasi-ballad, has a cool, creepy sound to it and is probably my favorite off of the second side. The remaining two songs are decent rockers in the same vein of all that's come before. What really brings down the album though, as the majority agrees, is the ten minute borefest "We Will Fall". You can guess that it was pretty much only on the record because the band wouldn't have had enough songs to fill the album space otherwise. And of course producer John Cale was in the Velvet Underground....and certainly that band would never have indulged in long, boring, pretentious drones.

Rating wise, the album is somewhere from a 7.5 to an 8. I'm leaning more in the direction of the former. As typical of many albums, the best songs are up front and the rest of the material can't reach their height. "We Will Fall", in particular, breaks this should've-been-classic down. Still, this album is a prime document of the 60s underground music scene. What endears me to the Stooges above their peers though, was that while the Velvet Underground were heroin addicts who sang about their freak scene and the MC5 were basically just hippies with louder guitars, the Stooges spoke for the bored and disillusioned. Anyone who often has had "another year with nothin' to do" can get into this (high school in a nutshell). Of course, the Stooges were also heroin addicts for the most part and hung with the same scene as the aforementioned bands, but well....uh....


 

 

Post a comment! - Back to top

 

Fun House ( 1970 )

10

Down On the Street / Loose / T.V. Eye / Dirt / 1970 / Fun House / L.A. Blues

FunhouseFun House, released merely a year later than their debut, is an insult to good taste and conventional expectations about rock music. The Stooges had already made it clear that these kids weren’t playing the game by the proper rules and preferred their own chaotic pamphlet instead. Nothing could have prepared the public for this however, since we’re dealing with one of the heaviest, most uncompromising and intense albums I’ve ever heard (imagine how it must have sounded in 1970). It sounds raw, primal, and at times even demented and downright chaotic. The drums are still as rudimentary as before (in each song), so it’s no use giving a detailed description. Similarly, the bass playing is limited to some simple figures employing just a few notes. Ron Asheton’s guitar sounds even dirtier than on the debut, although it’s less fuzzy now. The greatest improvement over the debut is Iggy Pop’s singing, though. His performances sound confidently possessed as he moans, snarls, screams, and grunts his way through this glorious 36-minutes mess of a record, the ultimate shot of adrenaline.

The pounding “Down On the Street” (probably the album’s most conventional song) immediately shows it’s getting serious now, with a vicious guitar attack (with two layers over each other during the chorus) that prepares for what is to come. It’s a song reduced to the very basics, taking rock almost back to avant-garde, and sounds wild and reckless. Even more violent (and fast) is the highly energetic “Loose,” and a notable thing about this song is the experimentation going on with the (dis)advantage of stereo sound, as a fuzzy guitar comes through the first channel, and a ‘cleaner’, wailing guitar through the other. The lyrics are really rudimentary (“I’ll stick it deep inside, cause I’m loose, I feel fine to be dancin’”) and Pop sounds positively out of his mind. The scream (“Looooooooooord”) that sets off “T.V. Eye” is followed by crunching guitar and then loud pumping bass (filling up an entire channel, sending the guitar back to the other one) and drums. Again, the lyrics (“See that cat, yeah I do mean you, she got a T.V. eye on me” etc) don’t seem very meaningful, but they weren’t interesting in the first place, Pop applying all his energy to his demented howling (later even ‘coughing’ and mumbling in a deep baritone which he would use more and more, also on his solo efforts). A highlight section in the song is the repeated “brother,” after which the music stops for a second and is reprised by the guitar and drums that finish the song. “Dirt” begins with a 6-note bass line and meanders slowly along while the interplay between Pop and Asheton’s guitar takes center stage, the guitar accentuating the lyrics “I’ve been HURT” with short bursts of wailing noise.

A blistering start to what used to be side B is given by the classic “1970” (a reference to “1969,” of course, and using the same bass line), as fast and belligerent as “Loose.” “I feel allright” is what Pop yells over and over again, but the way in which he pronounces it, in combination with the music, suggests he’s in a quite different mood/state (he may as well plant a knife in your back). The song also introduces sax player Steve Mackay, whose playing gets increasingly wild and chaotic, matching Pop’s outrageous yelps. “Fun House,” the album’s longest song (7:46), boasts another classic bass intro, and an exciting guitar/sax-battle, with both maniacally performing and trying to top each other, after which Pop starts ‘singing’ or bringing a psychotic imitation of James Brown, depending on your point of view. Both guitar and sax move to the background, but return to propel the song to a mad intensity only matched by the free jazz-interplay of Peter Brötzmann and Sonny Sharrock in Last Exit. The album closes with “L.A. Blues,” a culmination of all previous things, a chaotic wankfest of the highest order, with steadily rolling drums, screeching saxophone and wailing guitar. Rawer than anything before, it is a statement that can’t be ignored and a final chapter to an album that pushed rock ‘ roll to its outer limits. Some might argue that The Velvet Underground were first with their deconstructionist first two albums, but whereas the former were consciously turning excessive feedback into a heady art form, these thugs – spearheaded by rock’s foremost raving lunatic - were possessed by a hereto unmatched primal energy and wildness. The result is an astonishing blast of rock ‘n roll no self-proclaimed music fan should be without.

 

Reader comments:


Zophael979:
With all due respect to the Ramones, this is simply put the best example of how a band could do so much with so few chords. The words you used to describe this album are dead on. Raw. Primal. Uncompromising. It is all of these things and easily my favorite Stooges record.

Sonically, the first few songs are the same style as the first record, except that Ron Asheton cut down on the use of the wah-wah pedal (probably for the best, since it came pretty close to being overused on the debut) and Mr. Pop has taken up psychotic screaming to go along with his bored sneer. This combination really works. "Down On The Street" kicks the album off with an awesome, classic metal riff that segues into an extremely loud, intense chorus. Possible influence on the Pixies maybe? The second track, "Loose", is a bit faster and quite a bit crazier. The guitar riff on that song is also awesome and the beat is hypnotic. Then the intensity is upped again for "T.V. Eye", which is probably the album's best known song (simply because it can be heard on that damn car commercial...). "T.V. Eye" has the most memorable guitar riff of the album (which is saying a lot because Ron Asheton really did know what to do with those very few chords he used).

"Dirt" slows the tempo down to possibly the slowest crawl on any of the Stooges' three studio albums and manages to be one of the most strangely beautiful songs I've ever heard. I'm not sure whether it's the hypnotic beat, the GREAT bassline, Asheton's fuzzy waves of guitar noise, or Iggy's screams and moans, but something in that song manages to affect me in a weird way. Many songs aren't worth a seven minute length, but it would be a crime if this one were any shorter. "1970" returns to the rocking sound of the first three songs, but then a saxophone joins the song halfway through and descends into pure, utter craziness. This extends into the title track, which is more of a free jazz-styled jam than a rock song. Finally, the album concludes with "L.A. Blues", which is little more than four minutes of nothing but feedback and distortion, along without of control drums and saxophone. Normally, I hate such things, but this album feels like it earned it, as opposed to so many other bands who tack this stuff onto their records nowadays. It's hard to think of this album having a different ending. Now this record isn't for everyone and I could understand if someone said Raw Power is better. And, yes, the lyrics aren't exactly deep and meaningful. All of the songs are about banging (with self mutilation being thrown into "Dirt" for fun). However, the primal sexuality here is a much different animal than the ridiculous cock rock of Ted Nugent and the like. This record is simply put: primal. It takes me to a place. Add it all up and it's a clean ten in my book. As you said, no self-proclaimed music fan should be without it.


 

Post a comment! - Back to top

 

Raw Power (1973)


8.5

Search and Destroy / Gimme Danger / Your Pretty Face Is Going to Hell / Penetration / Raw Power / I Need Somebody / Shake Appeal / Death Trip


Raw PowerFor me, it all started with Henry Rollins. When I first witnessed (I must’ve been 15 or so) one of his shows, I was totally baffled by the guy’s stage behaviour, wasting no time on superfluous banter, just prowling there bended over, screaming his lungs out. Wearing nothing but a pair of shorts, that huge tattoo on his back caught my (and everyone else’s) attention: a huge sun that looked as if it announced the apocalypse and above it the words “SEARCH & DESTROY.” It certainly fitted the man (during those days he must have been one of the most intense performers on this planet) and it didn’t take me long to discover where he got it from. It was his own tribute to the wild Stooges-song bearing the same title, a song that conveyed the same sense of undiluted psychotic violence as Rollins’ performance on that day. It was also his tribute to Iggy Pop, the ultimate stage freak, who wasn't hesitant to take risks, and while it wasn’t Rollins’ shtick to provoke an audience, they shared the same dedication and primal approach. At the time, “Search and Destroy” must’ve sounded truly insane (I mean … Jackson Browne and James Taylor had replaced the psychedelic sounds in the charts, right?), and it does even now. By choosing that particular song, Rollins paid respect to the essence of rock ‘n roll, to not following the rules, to an outcast essence.

I mean, get your hands on a copy of Raw Power and listen. There are several versions around of the album, and all of them will do, but if you get the original Bowie mix, we’re dealing with the same album. There’s also the (rare) version that has the recordings before Bowie got his hands on the mix (which I never heard), and the late ‘90’s version (see cover photo above), produced by the Popster himself. What got into those guys when they recorded it during the summer of ’72, I don’t know, but the album sounds so incredibly fucked up and perverted at the same time. Play “Search and Destroy” and crank up the volume: objectively speaking, the mix is horrible – where’s the bass, where’s the drums? – but wait ‘till that guitar kicks in and Pop gets to that “Somebody’s gotta save my soul”-line and it falls into place. Everything about this song is grotesque, from the lyrics (“I’m streetwalkin’ cheetah with a heart full of napalm, I’m a runaway son of the nuclear A-bomb”), to Pop’s focused insanity, to the almost ridiculously blunt performance of the band, to, finally, that guitar sound that suggest Williamson’s going to slit your throat right after the song’s finished. Despite its “shortcomings”, “Search and Destroy” appealed to me like few songs did before. It was blood-raw, it was crass, extreme, threatening, it was a song that somehow seemed to have touched upon the essential core of rock music, or one that – like “Heartbreak Hotel,” “God Only Knows,” “Respect” or “The Great Valerio” – was possessed by some über-force, one that transcended 99% of all other attempts. This one was the exact opposite of, say, Brain Salad Surgery: a gigantic vital cry (despite the less confident message of the song – “I’m the world’s forgotten boy”), a life-confirming blast and a colossal kick under the butt. Pretty ironic, considering the fact it sounded like this because of some technical problems (or perhaps no one was capable of handling the equipment).

However, despite the magnitude of the opening song, the remainder of the album can’t really live up to that high standard. Whereas Fun House was about getting your face smeared on the pavement for 35 minutes, Raw Power starts off with one huge beating that’s followed by seven kicks in the groin, some being harder than others. There’s nothing here to suggest Pop and Williamson were a great team of songwriters, but there are some tracks that could be seen as ancestors of the songs and albums that would have a large impact on the rock scene a few years later. “Raw Power,” for instance, is a blueprint for lots of simple, rock ‘n roll-based punk rock, sounding blunt and wild, and that one-note piano thing would be recycled by literally hundreds of bands. The sludge and chaos of Fun House has largely been replaced by more accessible garage rock and – blasphemy! – the use of acoustic guitars during “Gimme Danger.” It doesn’t seem that interesting in the beginning, but the steadily intensifying nature of the song, Pop’s deranged howling and some great guitar parts make it pretty damn convincing. “Your Pretty Face Is Going to Hell” (originally titled “Hard to beat”) sounds like a demo recording and is basically another old-fashioned rock ‘n roll song played by a few madmen, but it also goes to show that the band’s sound wasn't that far removed from the Stones' sound, as Williamson’s riffs could’ve been Richards’ if the latter drunk kerosene instead of booze and played with iron nails instead of a pick. Album closer “Death Trip” probably sounds the worst of all, with the guitar sound just disappearing completely now and then, but it’s again Pop’s deranged vocals and Williamson’s equally demented solo near the end that’ll have you raise your eyebrows and mutter “What the fuck?”.

Some people will probably try to convince you the entire album is manna from heaven, but that’s not how I hear it: “Penetration” has a nice swampy sound, the slow and bluesy “I Need Somebody” is something of a surprise (a concession?), and the primitive “Shake Appeal” sounds like the Flamin’ Groovies on speed. As suggested repeatedly, these songs are good, but nowhere near as invigorating as the track that kicks the album off. How could it be? Most artists never make/write/record such a great song in their entire multi-decade career. Again, it’s quite ironic that such an uncontrolled bunch of guys was capable of that. They went further than any other act at the time: The Velvet Underground regarded conventions with disdain and sang about cough syrup and other illegal substances, The MC5 kicked more ass than a premier league rugby team, and The Stones were supposed to deliver the ultimate rock ‘n roll experience, but not one band took it as far as Iggy and The Stooges. This band should be considered as nothing less than an essential band in the (d)evolution of rock – music as we know it today wouldn’t have existed without these guys – a band that took risks, didn’t give a fuck about anyone or anything and made one undisputed all-time classic (in my book) and a final studio album that’s “graced” by one of the greatest songs of all time, to which the rest is a first-class bonus. OK, that last remark didn’t make sense and this ‘review’ was one long incoherent rambling, but don’t forget I’m not the one who’s getting paid to do this kind of stuff. Chuck Eddy is.

 

Reader comments:


Zophael979:
You're dead on with your review of Raw Power. It doesn't reach the heights of Fun House, but it's a great record in it's own right. There have been times when I didn't always think so. The most jarring thing about Raw Power when you compare it to Iggy and company's earlier work is the difference in guitar sound, due of course to a different guitarist in Mr. Williamson. His style is more like what would become the signature thrash metal style. A bit of a contrast to the fuzzed out, grungey guitar stylings of Ron Asheton. In fact, one of the reasons I prefer Fun House is because I prefer Asheton's playing to Williamson's.

However that's not to say that Williamson wasn't good or he didn't have his moments. Simply put, "Search and Destroy" is one of the greatest rock songs ever written. It was faster than anything the Stooges (or possibly anyone) had done up to that point. The riff. The solos. The ungodly intense performance by both the band and frontman Iggy Pop, who just COMPLETELY freaked out as the song came to a close. Probably my favorite Stooges song, though "I Wanna Be Your Dog" and "T.V. Eye" might deserve that title as well. In stark contrast to the take-no-prisoners opener, "Gimme Danger" starts with a pretty folkish melody played on an acoustic guitar. Just when we think the Stooges have decided to take a stab at an actual ballad, however, is when the sludgy electric guitars riffs come in and so does Iggy's deranged howling. Punk and alternative bands in the future would imitate this trick to the point where it's become clique. Yet "Gimme Danger" still works for me every time I hear it.

"Your Pretty Face Is Going To Hell" is basically an early thrash song with a bit of a stonsey swagger and nasty vocals by Pop to match. However, it goes on nearly five minutes, which is a bit too long for a thrash number. Thankfully it's followed by a starkly different song in "Penetration", a thematic sequel to the previous album's "Loose". It's the slowest and definitely the calmest number of the record (though they're aren't really any calm songs per se). The Asheton brothers are basically there to keep it steady while Williamson lays down some great guitar and Iggy turns in one of his best vocal performances where he just sounds positively EVIL. The title track is good, mostly just mid-tempo chord bashing reaching higher and higher levels of intensity with a nice little riff during the chorus parts.

"I Need Somebody" provides another left turn with a big, heavy, bluesy stomp, layered with some melodic acoustic guitars. Not really a ballad and I really wouldn't call it a concession either. The band were supposedly heading into a distinctly bluesy direction when they broke up and I see this song as more of indication as to what would've come had the band not imploded. Personally, I think this new direction would've been interesting.

"Shake Appeal" does the amazing and recaptures the raw feel of all those great 50s and early Beatles recordings. I think of it as the Stooges' equivalent to "I Saw Her Standing There" or "Maybelline" or whatever. "Death Trip" closes the album well enough, but does go on a bit too long and gets my vote the least interesting song on the record. This brings me to another reason of why I prefer Fun House. Perhaps "L.A. Blues" was little more than noise and screaming, but it gave an awesome climax to the album.

If anything, Raw Power is easier to get into than it's predecessors and more likely to be embraced by fans of modern metal and modern rock, thanks to the aforementioned difference in Williamson's guitar style compared to Asheton. Is it the most violent sounding record ever? I think Black Flag's Damaged or a few of those damn Big Black records might provide competition for that. However, Raw Power is an essential recording in 70s American Punk and certainly one of the best records to come from that scene. It blows away the Sex Pistols and the New York Dolls for sure. And it's thankfully consistent. I give it a very high 9.


 

Post a comment! - Back to top

 

Read album reviews of similar or related artists: Henry Rollins (Solo) - Rollins Band - Henry Rollins Live - Iggy Pop - The Hives

 

Back to album review index

Disclaimer: All reviews and other written material on the entire site are copyright ©2002-2005 of Guy Peters. Webdesign and other techie stuff is copyright ©2002-2005 of Els De Clercq. Nothing on this site can be used without explicit permission (which can easily be obtained by asking us). Don't steal our stuff! Photo's and/or images are copyright of the respective bands and/or their label/music reps, unless otherwise stated. All logos and trademarks in this site are property of their respective owner. No infringment was intended.